What the data shows
What does the revival of David Hare’s Teeth ‘n’ Smiles reveal about the current state of theatre? The answer lies in the performance of Rebecca Lucy Taylor, who plays the character Maggie Frisby. Taylor, also known as the pop star Self Esteem, has been described as “sensational” in her role, showcasing a blend of self-loathing and resilience that resonates with audiences.
The play, set during a chaotic gig at a university ball in 1969, has been brought back to life at the Duke of York’s Theatre and will run until June 6, 2026. Critics have given the production an average rating of 3.2 stars, with some praising Taylor’s performance while others question the relevance of the material in 2026.
Directed by Daniel Raggett, Teeth ‘n’ Smiles is a revival of Hare’s original work from 1973, first staged at the Royal Court in 1975. The play features original songs by Nick and Tony Bicât, adding a contemporary flair to the historical narrative. Critics have noted the compelling nature of Self Esteem’s live performances, further enhancing the theatrical experience.
Despite the mixed reviews, Taylor’s portrayal of Maggie has garnered significant attention. Sarah Crompton remarked, “Taylor is sensational as Maggie, full of self-loathing and fight in almost equal measure, staggering around the stage but never going down.” This highlights the depth of her character and the emotional weight she brings to the production.
However, not all reviews have been favorable. Critics like Fiona Mountford have questioned the play’s relevance, stating, “Does it have anything of burning import to say to us in 2026? The awkward answer is a resounding ‘No.'” This sentiment raises important questions about the value of reviving older works in today’s cultural landscape.
As the production continues, audiences and critics alike will be watching closely to see if the play can maintain its momentum and relevance. The number of theatremakers who rely on platforms like The Stage for news and reviews is significant, with over 100,000 individuals engaged in the industry. This underscores the importance of critical reception for productions like Teeth ‘n’ Smiles.
Details remain unconfirmed regarding future performances and potential adaptations of the play. As it stands, the revival has sparked conversation about the intersection of historical narratives and contemporary issues, making it a noteworthy event in the London theatre scene.